Update on the Sunny Valley Sand and Gravel Mine Application

For the past eight years, Rogue Advocates has been actively engaged in reviewing and challenging the proposed Sunny Valley Sand and Gravel (SVSG) mine project on Graves Creek, just upstream from the Wild and Scenic Rogue River. This project poses significant risks to our region’s water, wildlife, and communities, and we remain committed to monitoring every step of the permitting process.

Why a New Application Was Required

The original Josephine County land use hearings on SVSG concluded years ago with 42 Conditions of Approval placed on the project. Afterward, the company filed for a state permit through the Oregon Department of Geology and Mineral Industries (DOGAMI). However, DOGAMI determined that the County’s conditions significantly altered the mine operations, requiring SVSG to submit a new application in 2024.

DOGAMI has the authority to impose additional conditions, which can be expensive and difficult for operators to meet, but rarely denies applications outright. This makes close oversight of the process and collaboration with partner organizations essential.

Current Review Status

DOGAMI’s review of the updated application is now underway:

• Fall 2024: SVSG submitted its revised operating proposal.
• Early 2025: DOGAMI staff, led by reviewer John Hook, is examining the details. If deficiencies are found, DOGAMI will require revisions from SVSG before moving forward.
• Agency Review: Once the application is complete, it will be sent to agencies including Oregon Water Resources, Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife, DEQ, and Josephine County for comment.
• Final Permit Draft: DOGAMI will revise the permit based on agency feedback and any applicant responses.

Unlike the County land use process, DOGAMI does not hold public hearings. While public comments may be submitted, agency recommendations generally carry more weight in shaping the permit.

Our Role and Partnerships

Rogue Advocates is working closely with community and conservation partners to ensure this proposal receives rigorous scrutiny:

• Friends of Country Living (Sunny Valley residents): Requested a copy of the new application from DOGAMI.
• WaterWatch (Attorney Lisa Brown): Providing expertise on Oregon Water Resources issues.
• Rogue Riverkeeper and Native Fish Society: Supporting analysis of impacts to fish, water quality, and habitat.

Together, we are building a strong coalition to hold both SVSG and DOGAMI accountable.

How the Public Can Engage

The most impactful way for community members to weigh in may be through Josephine County Planning, though this will be a challenging venue given that SVSG is owned by Andreas Blech, the county’s current unelected Commissioner. Still, public opinion remains a powerful voice — especially when coordinated and persistent.

---

Key Takeaways

Step	What’s Happening	How It Matters
New Application	DOGAMI required SVSG to reapply due to significant changes.	Ensures updated conditions are fully reviewed.
DOGAMI Review	Staff evaluating deficiencies and requesting revisions.	Process could take months; conditions may increase costs.
Agency Input	State and local agencies provide feedback.	Their comments strongly shape the final permit.
Public Role	Limited in DOGAMI process; stronger through County Planning.	Collective public pressure can influence outcomes.

---

Moving Forward

Rogue Advocates will continue to track the SVSG application closely and collaborate with partners to protect the Rogue River watershed. We’ll keep the community informed as the process develops and highlight opportunities for public involvement.

Explore more about our recent accomplishments, learn about other land use cases, or stay updated through our news and updates page.

Stay tuned, and stay engaged. Your voice matters.